201 E. High St. Toledo

Otterbein Apartments was a rare Art Moderne church in Toledo, IA that was built in 1946 on the site of the former First United Brethren Church which burned down in 1943. The current building is individually listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Otterbein now houses 11 high-end apartments that range from studio to 2-bedroom.
Rent ranges from $480 to $1300 and include water, sewer, and trash. Tenants will be responsible for electric, cable, and internet (optional). Each unit has unique features that combine the modern style with the historic church accents. These units are currently open to lease with move-in FALL 2018!


  • Open floor plans
  • Historic architectural details
  • Full kitchen and appliance package
  • Granite/quartz countertops
  • Walk-in showers
  • Washer/Dryer
  • Central air/heat
  • Security

Floor Plans





  • Date Format: MM slash DD slash YYYY